Skip to Content

13 Reasons You Should Never Buy a Dog From a Breeder – No Matter the Breed

13 Reasons You Should Never Buy a Dog From a Breeder – No Matter the Breed

Every dog deserves a loving home, but not every home should come from a breeder.

While purebred puppies may seem irresistible, the hidden cost of breeding is heartbreaking. Shelters overflow with dogs desperate for a second chance, yet people continue to pay top dollar for designer pets. The truth? Every breeder sale keeps a shelter dog locked behind bars.

It’s not just about overcrowded shelters. Breeding practices often prioritize profit over ethics, leading to genetic disorders, cruel puppy mills, and heartbreaking medical conditions. Even so-called “reputable” breeders can’t justify the thousands of dogs euthanized each year simply because they weren’t bought in time.

Before you hand over money for a breeder puppy, take a moment to think about the consequences. There are 13 powerful reasons why buying from a breeder is the wrong choice—no matter the breed.

Contributing to Overpopulation

Contributing to Overpopulation
© PETA

Purchasing dogs from breeders can exacerbate the already existing problem of pet overpopulation. Shelters are crowded with adorable dogs needing homes, and by choosing to buy rather than adopt, we inadvertently contribute to the issue.

These dogs in shelters are often left waiting for homes that may never come. By adopting from a shelter, one can help mitigate this problem and give a dog a second chance.

Being a responsible dog owner means considering the broader impact of our choices on the canine world.

Health Issues in Purebreds

Health Issues in Purebreds
© Tri-County Times

Many purebred dogs are prone to genetic health problems due to limited gene pools. Conditions such as hip dysplasia, heart disease, and respiratory problems are common in certain breeds.

These health issues often result in significant veterinary costs and can shorten a dog’s lifespan. Adopting a mixed-breed dog can often mean fewer health problems, as they benefit from a more diverse genetic pool.

Ensuring a healthy life for your pet should be a priority, and adopting can be a better path to achieving this.

Ethical Concerns with Breeding Practices

Ethical Concerns with Breeding Practices
© Paws in Work

Breeding facilities, often referred to as puppy mills, prioritize profit over animal welfare. These establishments frequently keep dogs in cramped, unsanitary conditions without proper veterinary care.

Such environments are detrimental to the dogs’ physical and emotional well-being. Supporting breeders inadvertently supports these unethical practices.

Adopting from shelters promotes humane treatment of animals and ensures you’re not contributing to these exploitative practices.

High Costs of Buying from Breeders

High Costs of Buying from Breeders
© Canine Journal

Purchasing a dog from a breeder can be extremely costly, with prices reaching thousands of dollars. This doesn’t include the additional expenses for medical care, training, and supplies.

Adopting a dog from a shelter is significantly more affordable, often including vaccinations and microchipping in the adoption fee.

Saving money on initial costs allows new pet owners to focus on providing excellent care for their new companion.

Supporting Adoption Saves Lives

Supporting Adoption Saves Lives
© North Shore Animal League

Every dog adopted from a shelter means one less dog euthanized due to overpopulation. It is an impactful way to save lives and make a difference.

Many shelters face capacity issues, leading to difficult decisions about euthanizing animals that aren’t adopted.

Choosing adoption supports these organizations and the good work they do, while possibly saving the life of a loving dog looking for a home.

Behavioral Issues in Bred Dogs

Behavioral Issues in Bred Dogs
© CareCredit

Dogs bred for specific traits may develop behavioral issues if those traits are not properly managed. For instance, herding dogs may exhibit nipping behaviors.

Without adequate outlets for their energy, these dogs can become frustrated and difficult to manage, leading to potential abandonment.

Mixed-breed dogs often display a more balanced temperament, providing a wonderful pet experience without the behavioral concerns.

Limited Genetic Diversity

Limited Genetic Diversity
© Veterinary Genetics Laboratory – UC Davis

Purebred dogs have limited genetic diversity, increasing susceptibility to diseases and health issues. This lack of diversity can affect their immune systems and overall vitality.

The pursuit of specific traits often overshadows the importance of genetic variety, leading to compromised health.

Adopting from a shelter offers pets with varied backgrounds, enhancing genetic diversity and reducing genetic health risks.

Unexpected Temperament Issues

Unexpected Temperament Issues
© Wag!

Purebred dogs are often praised for predictable traits, but this isn’t always the case. Individual dogs may not conform to breed standards, exhibiting unexpected temperaments.

These surprises can lead to challenges in managing the dog’s behavior, resulting in a difficult living situation.

Shelter dogs are evaluated for temperament before adoption, providing a better understanding of their behavior and compatibility with your family.

Breeding and Animal Rights Violations

Breeding and Animal Rights Violations
© Virginia Mercury

Breeding practices can involve serious animal rights violations. Dogs used for breeding often live in poor conditions, deprived of socialization and proper care.

These violations highlight the need for stricter regulations and ethical considerations in the breeding industry.

Adopting from shelters supports animal welfare and rights, ensuring dogs are treated humanely and compassionately.

Breeder Puppies and Early Separation

Breeder Puppies and Early Separation
© Rover.com

Breeder puppies are sometimes separated from their mothers too early, affecting their emotional development. This premature separation can lead to anxiety and behavioral issues.

Puppies need time with their mothers for proper socialization and learning critical life skills.

Adopting from a shelter can help ensure that puppies or dogs have had adequate time to develop these essential skills, leading to a healthier, happier pet.

Lack of Support from Breeders

Lack of Support from Breeders
© The Spruce Pets

While reputable breeders may offer support, many disappear once the transaction is complete. New owners are left without guidance or help.

This lack of support can be challenging, especially when dealing with health or behavioral issues.

Shelters and rescue organizations often provide ongoing support and advice, ensuring a successful transition for both the dog and the owner.

Impact on Local Shelters

Impact on Local Shelters
© WFAA

Choosing breeders over shelters affects local shelters, which rely on adoptions to continue their operations.

Every dog bought from a breeder is one less adoption, straining shelter resources and limiting their ability to care for more animals.

Supporting shelters helps them continue rescuing and caring for dogs in need, fostering a humane community for pets.

Encouraging Responsible Pet Ownership

Encouraging Responsible Pet Ownership
© MSPCA-Angell

Adopting from a shelter encourages responsible pet ownership, promoting the values of compassion and care.

Prospective owners learn about the importance of providing a loving, permanent home and the responsibilities that come with it.

This experience fosters a deeper appreciation for the pet-owner relationship and encourages positive involvement in the animal community.