Skip to Content

17 Myths About Rescue Cats That Are Keeping Shelters Full

17 Myths About Rescue Cats That Are Keeping Shelters Full

Rescue cats aren’t broken—they’re just misunderstood.

Some people act like adopting a rescue cat is signing up for drama.
Too wild. Too old. Too shy. Too damaged.
The rumors swirl, and these myths stick like fur on a black sweater.

But let’s be honest—most of these “facts” are total fiction.

The truth? Rescue cats are just cats. They nap in sunbeams, chase string, demand snacks, and sometimes act like tiny, judgmental roommates.
They’re not lost causes—they’re lost opportunities for joy, mischief, and love.

Every myth that lingers means another cat waiting behind a cage door.
And every busted myth? That’s a life closer to a second chance.

Let’s talk about the 17 myths that are keeping too many rescue cats from the homes they deserve.
Spoiler alert: most of them are complete nonsense.

Myth 1: Rescue Cats are Unhealthy

Myth 1: Rescue Cats are Unhealthy
© Kinship

Many believe that rescue cats are unhealthy or carry diseases, but this isn’t true. Shelters ensure cats are vaccinated, treated for any illnesses, and given regular check-ups.

Typically, when you adopt a rescue cat, you receive a healthy pet. Moreover, shelters provide medical history and support, ensuring new owners are well-informed. This notion stems from seeing cats in cages, but remember: shelters prioritize their well-being.

Adopting a rescue cat means gaining a loyal friend, not a sickly animal. These cats often blossom in loving environments, showing their true vitality and zest for life.

Myth 2: Rescue Cats Have Behavioral Issues

Myth 2: Rescue Cats Have Behavioral Issues
© Newsweek

Some think rescue cats have behavior issues due to past trauma, but many cats in shelters are there for reasons unrelated to their temperament. Cats might be surrendered due to allergies, moving, or owner lifestyle changes.

In fact, rescue cats often display gratitude and affection. Shelters assess each cat’s personality, helping match them with suitable adopters. With patience and understanding, these cats thrive, forming deep bonds with their new families.

Their resilience is remarkable, and many adapt quickly, showing their true character once they feel secure.

Myth 3: Kittens are Better than Adults

Myth 3: Kittens are Better than Adults
© Purina New Zealand

While kittens are undeniably cute, adult rescue cats offer distinct advantages. They often have established personalities, making it easier to find a good match. Adults are typically less mischievous and require less supervision than playful kittens.

Moreover, mature cats are usually litter-trained and understand basic household rules. Adopting an adult cat means bypassing the unpredictable kitten phase.

These seasoned companions are perfect for those seeking a calm, predictable pet experience. Their appreciation for a second chance at life is evident, forming loyal, loving relationships with their adopters.

Myth 4: Rescue Cats Can’t Bond with New Owners

Myth 4: Rescue Cats Can't Bond with New Owners
© Hickory Veterinary and Specialty Hospital

A common misconception is that rescue cats are too detached or aloof to bond with new owners. In reality, many rescue cats quickly form strong, affectionate relationships.

Once given a stable environment, these cats often reveal their true personalities, full of love and trust. The bond between a rescue cat and its owner can be incredibly rewarding.

These cats, grateful for their second chance, often become devoted companions. Patience and affection are key, and soon, you’ll find your rescue cat curling up with you, offering purrs of gratitude and contentment.

Myth 5: Rescue Cats Aren’t Good with Kids

Myth 5: Rescue Cats Aren't Good with Kids
© Kinship

Fears that rescue cats won’t get along with children are unfounded. Many rescue cats thrive in family environments, showing gentleness and patience. Shelters often evaluate a cat’s temperament, ensuring they match families with suitable pets.

Rescue cats can teach kids empathy and responsibility. Introducing cats and kids under supervision fosters mutual respect and understanding. Over time, these cats become cherished playmates and confidants.

Their adaptability and gentle nature make them a wonderful addition to any family, disproving the myth that they’re unsuitable for homes with children.

Myth 6: Rescue Cats are Old and Boring

Myth 6: Rescue Cats are Old and Boring
© YuMOVE

The belief that rescue cats are all old and lack energy is misleading. Shelters house cats of all ages, from lively kittens to sprightly seniors. Many adult rescue cats retain kitten-like playfulness, engaging with toys and games.

Adopting a rescue cat offers a range of personalities and energy levels to match any household. Older cats can be just as engaging as young ones, enjoying interactive play and affection.

Their playful antics often bring joy and laughter, proving that age does not dampen a cat’s spirit or capacity for fun.

Myth 7: Rescue Cats Have Short Lifespans

Myth 7: Rescue Cats Have Short Lifespans
© Pumpkin Pet Insurance

Concerns about rescue cats having shorter lifespans are misplaced. With proper care, nutrition, and veterinary attention, rescue cats can live long, healthy lives, just like any other cat.

The key is providing a loving home and regular vet visits. Many rescue cats thrive in nurturing environments, often surpassing life expectancy due to the love and care they receive.

Their longevity is testament to their resilience and the effectiveness of adoption programs. Giving a rescue cat a family means gaining a companion who will share your life for many years.

Myth 8: Rescue Cats Can’t Live with Other Pets

Myth 8: Rescue Cats Can't Live with Other Pets
© K9 Time

It’s often assumed that rescue cats can’t coexist with other pets, but this is far from true. Many rescue cats are adaptable and can live harmoniously with other animals, given proper introductions.

Shelters frequently test how well cats interact with other pets, providing insights for potential adopters. With patience and gradual introductions, rescue cats often form bonds with their furry housemates.

They learn to share spaces and even engage in play, proving that rescue cats can be sociable and friendly, even with other species.

Myth 9: Rescue Cats are Set in Their Ways

Myth 9: Rescue Cats are Set in Their Ways
© Newsweek

The idea that rescue cats are inflexible or resistant to change is a myth. Many rescue cats adapt remarkably well to new environments, showing curiosity and intelligence.

Shelters work to socialize cats, preparing them for life in a variety of settings. Once in a new home, these cats often enjoy exploring and learning about their surroundings. They’re not set in their ways; rather, they relish new experiences and opportunities.

Given time, rescue cats often surprise their owners with their adaptability and eagerness to adjust to new routines.

Myth 10: Rescue Cats are Not Purebred

Myth 10: Rescue Cats are Not Purebred
© Purebred Kitties

While many rescue cats are mixed breeds, shelters occasionally have purebred cats available for adoption. Owners may surrender purebreds due to unforeseen circumstances, meaning households seeking specific breeds can still find them in rescues.

These cats offer the same companionship and love as any other, without the need for expensive breeders. Adopting a purebred from a shelter supports rescue efforts and provides a home to a cat in need.

Whether mixed or purebred, each rescue cat is unique and deserving of a loving family.

Myth 11: Rescue Cats Have No History

Myth 11: Rescue Cats Have No History
© Newsweek

Some worry that rescue cats lack known backgrounds, but shelters often gather detailed information about each cat. This includes health records, behavioral assessments, and any known history.

Staff members are usually familiar with each cat’s story and can provide valuable insights to adopters. This enables potential owners to make informed decisions and find a cat that fits their lifestyle.

Rescue cats may come from varied pasts, but shelters ensure they are well-documented and ready for adoption. This transparency helps build trust and assurance for new pet owners.

Myth 12: Rescue Cats are Too Independent

Myth 12: Rescue Cats are Too Independent
© Best Friends Animal Society

The notion that rescue cats are overly independent overlooks their potential for companionship. Many rescue cats crave interaction and develop close bonds with their owners. Given time and attention, they become affectionate, social pets.

These cats may follow their owners around, participate in daily activities, and offer companionship without being invasive. Their independence doesn’t preclude affection; rather, it enhances the relationship as they respect personal space while still seeking connection.

Rescue cats strike a balance, making them ideal companions for those seeking both independence and closeness.

Myth 13: Rescue Cats Require Special Care

Myth 13: Rescue Cats Require Special Care
© Britannica

While some rescue cats may have special needs, the majority require standard cat care. This includes regular feeding, grooming, and vet visits, similar to any other cat.

Shelters provide potential adopters with detailed care instructions, ensuring a smooth transition. For those worried about special requirements, staff can offer guidance and support.

Most rescue cats adapt well to new routines and environments, thriving with typical care. Understanding each cat’s needs helps dispel the myth that they’re high-maintenance. Adopters often find rescue cats to be loving, low-maintenance companions.

Myth 14: Rescue Cats are Difficult to Train

Myth 14: Rescue Cats are Difficult to Train
© Sparkle Cat

Contrary to belief, many rescue cats are highly trainable. With positive reinforcement and patience, they can learn commands, tricks, and routines. Training provides mental stimulation, strengthening the bond between owner and cat.

Shelters often start basic training, making it easier for new owners to continue. These cats enjoy the challenge and engagement training provides.

From simple commands to more complex behaviors, rescue cats can surprise their owners with their intelligence and willingness to learn. Dispelling the myth of untrainability opens up opportunities for rewarding interactions.

Myth 15: Rescue Cats are Not as Loving

Myth 15: Rescue Cats are Not as Loving
© Lilly Brush

The perception that rescue cats are less loving is unfounded. Many rescue cats form deep, loving bonds with their adopters, often showing immense gratitude for their new homes.

Their affection can rival that of any other pet, providing companionship and joy. Rescue cats often seek out affection, curling up for cuddles and offering gentle nudges. Their love is unconditional, blossoming as they feel secure and cherished.

These cats’ capacity for affection disproves the myth, as they demonstrate loyalty and love in abundance to those who welcome them into their lives.

Myth 16: Rescue Cats are Hard to Find

Myth 16: Rescue Cats are Hard to Find
© Blue Cross

Contrary to belief, rescue cats are widely available in many locations. Shelters and adoption centers house numerous cats of all ages and breeds, ready for their forever homes.

Online platforms and local organizations facilitate the adoption process, connecting potential owners with cats in need. This accessibility means finding a rescue cat is often easier than expected.

By visiting shelters or exploring adoption websites, people can find their perfect feline companion. Dispelling this myth encourages more adoptions, helping shelters find homes for numerous deserving cats.

Myth 17: Black Cats Are Bad Luck

Myth 17: Black Cats Are Bad Luck
© Pop Goes The Babble

The superstition that black cats bring bad luck is a myth that unfortunately affects their adoption rates. In reality, black cats are just as loving and delightful as any other cat.

Many cultures even view them as symbols of good luck and prosperity. Their striking appearance adds to their charm, making them unique companions. By embracing black cats, adopters can enjoy their enchanting personalities and beauty.

This myth’s persistence only serves to keep these wonderful cats in shelters when they deserve loving homes.