Cat theft is real—and it’s on the rise.
Across the U.S., certain breeds are being snatched right from homes, porches, and even backyards. Why? Because some cats are just that wanted. We’re talking high price tags, rare looks, and personalities people will go to extreme lengths to claim.
These aren’t random strays. They’re Instagram-famous faces, show-quality charmers, and designer breeds that turn heads at every vet visit.
From silky exotics to sassy divas, here are the 20 cat breeds most likely to be stolen in America—and the reasons why thieves can’t seem to resist them. Keep your kitty close.
Siamese
Siamese cats, with their sleek bodies and striking blue eyes, are an epitome of elegance. Known for their vocal nature and affectionate behavior, they form deep bonds with their human companions.
Their enchanting personalities make them highly sought after, often landing them on the list of the most stolen breeds. This breed’s distinct coloring and loyal demeanor make them irresistible to cat enthusiasts and thieves alike.
A fun fact about Siamese cats is their origin in Thailand, where they were revered as sacred temple guardians, adding to their mystical allure.
Maine Coon
With their majestic size and bushy tails, Maine Coons are the gentle giants of the cat world. These cats are beloved for their laid-back personalities and dog-like loyalty.
Their friendly nature and impressive appearance make them a frequent target for cat thieves. Maine Coons, often described as ‘dog-like,’ follow their owners around and exhibit playful antics.
Interestingly, Maine Coons are one of the oldest natural breeds in North America, rumored to have arrived in the U.S. aboard Viking ships, contributing to their legendary status.
Bengal
With their exotic, leopard-like appearance, Bengal cats are every bit as wild as they look. Their energetic nature and intelligence make them a captivating addition to any home.
These attributes also make Bengals a prime target for theft, as their unique coats are highly prized. Bengals are known for their love of water and ability to learn tricks, adding to their desirability.
Originating from a cross between domestic cats and wild Asian leopards, their lineage adds an element of the wild to domestic life, making them both fascinating and sought after.
Persian
Persian cats are the epitome of feline royalty, with their long, luscious fur and expressive eyes. Known for their gentle and calm demeanor, they are the perfect companions for a serene home environment.
Their extravagant appearance and sweet disposition often make them a target for cat thieves. Persians’ need for grooming adds to their allure, as their coats require meticulous care.
Historically, Persians were favored by royalty and aristocrats, adding an air of sophistication and history to their already charming personalities.
Ragdoll
Ragdolls, with their striking blue eyes and plush coats, are known for their relaxed and floppy demeanor when held, hence their name. These cats are affectionate and gentle, making them ideal for families.
Their amiable nature makes them prone to theft, as they are easygoing and trusting of strangers. Ragdolls are famous for their dog-like behavior, often greeting their owners at the door.
The breed was developed in California in the 1960s, and their unique temperament has won them fans worldwide, further increasing their desirability.
British Shorthair
The British Shorthair, with its plush coat and round face, exudes both charm and serenity. Known for their easygoing nature and independence, they are a favorite among cat lovers everywhere.
Their appealing appearance and calm demeanor make them attractive targets for thieves. British Shorthairs are often associated with the famous ‘Cheshire Cat’ from Alice in Wonderland, adding to their appeal.
These cats are one of the oldest known breeds, with a history dating back to the Roman Empire, providing them with a sense of timeless elegance and mystery.
Russian Blue
The Russian Blue, with its shimmering gray coat and vivid green eyes, is a picture of elegance and mystery. Known for their gentle demeanor and playful personality, they are a treasured companion.
Their stunning appearance and affectionate nature make them a target for thieves. Russian Blues are often shy with strangers, yet form deep bonds with their families.
Legend has it they originated from the Archangel Isles of Russia, further deepening their mystique and allure, making them one of the most coveted breeds across the globe.
Sphynx
Known for their lack of fur and unique appearance, Sphynx cats are truly a spectacle. Their wrinkled skin and large ears give them an otherworldly charm that draws attention wherever they go.
Their distinct look and affectionate nature make them both adored and a target for theft. Sphynx cats are highly social and thrive on human attention.
Despite their unusual appearance, they are one of the warmest breeds, both in personality and temperature, requiring special care due to their lack of fur, which adds to their unique allure.
Scottish Fold
Scottish Folds, with their distinctive folded ears and round eyes, possess a sweet and gentle nature that is hard to resist. They quickly become beloved family members with their playful and loving behavior.
Their unique appearance makes them highly desirable, often leading to theft. Scottish Folds are known for their owl-like look, which captivates cat lovers worldwide.
These cats originated from a farm in Scotland, and their unusual ears are a result of a natural mutation, further adding to their charm and mystique.
Abyssinian
Abyssinians, with their sleek bodies and ticked coats, are one of the most energetic and playful cat breeds. Their curious and adventurous nature makes them a joy to have in any household.
This lively breed’s active lifestyle makes them targets for theft, as their vibrant personalities are highly appealing. Abyssinians are often described as being ‘clowns’ of the cat world.
With origins tracing back to ancient Egypt, where they were revered, Abyssinians carry a sense of historical prestige that adds to their allure and energy.
Oriental Shorthair
The Oriental Shorthair, with its sleek lines and large ears, is a cat of elegance and poise. Known for their striking appearance and intelligence, these cats are beloved by many.
Their unique look and dynamic personality make them targets for cat thieves. Oriental Shorthairs are known for their vocal nature and forming strong bonds with their owners.
Descendants of Siamese cats, they come in a variety of colors and patterns, offering diversity in their beauty, making them a fascinating choice for cat enthusiasts.
Burmese
Burmese cats, with their glossy coats and striking golden eyes, are known for their affectionate nature and playful demeanor. These cats form deep bonds with their families, making them cherished companions.
Their charming personality and striking appearance make them prone to theft. Burmese are often called ‘velcro cats’ due to their tendency to stay close to their humans.
Originally from Burma, they hold a regal history and were once considered sacred, adding a layer of allure and intrigue to their already captivating presence.
Norwegian Forest Cat
Norwegian Forest Cats, with their thick coats and bushy tails, are built for the great outdoors. Known for their robust and playful nature, they are a delight to watch in action.
These cats’ beauty and rugged charm make them targets for thieves. Described as ‘gentle giants,’ they are affectionate and loyal companions.
They have a rich history in Norse mythology, believed to have traveled with the Vikings. Their historical significance and majestic appearance make them an enchanting addition to any family.
Tonkinese
Tonkinese cats, with their striking aqua eyes and sleek coats, are a perfect blend of beauty and intelligence. Known for their sociable and playful nature, they are a joy in any home.
Their vibrant personalities and unique appearance make them a target for theft. Tonkinese are famous for their vocal nature and love for interactive play.
A hybrid of Siamese and Burmese breeds, they combine the best of both worlds, offering affectionate companionship and an exotic look that captivates cat enthusiasts.
Devon Rex
The Devon Rex, with its curly coat and large, bright eyes, is a truly unique feline. Known for their mischievous and playful nature, these cats are a source of endless entertainment.
Their unusual appearance and lively personality make them a target for theft. Devon Rex cats are often described as having a ‘pixie’ or ‘elfin’ look.
Originating from England, their quirky appearance and endearing antics have won them fans worldwide, making them a beloved and sought-after breed among cat lovers.
Birman
Birmans, with their captivating blue eyes and silky coats, are known for their gentle and loving nature. These cats are often described as ‘dog-like’ due to their friendly and playful demeanor.
Their striking appearance and affectionate personality make them targets for cat thieves. Birmans are famous for their beautiful white paws and striking color points.
According to legend, these sacred cats were companions to temple priests in Burma, and their serene nature continues to enchant cat enthusiasts today.
Savannah
Savannah cats, with their tall, elegant bodies and spotted coats, are a sight to behold. Known for their adventurous spirit and high energy, they are a thrilling addition to any household.
Their exotic looks and playful nature make them targets for theft. Savannahs are known for their ability to leap great heights and their love of water.
A cross between domestic cats and African Servals, they bring a touch of the wild into domestic life, making them both captivating and highly sought after.
Ragamuffin
Ragamuffins, with their plush, dense coats and warm, expressive eyes, are known for their calm and affectionate nature. These gentle giants are a comforting presence in any home.
Their sweet disposition and striking appearance make them targets for cat thieves. Ragamuffins are often compared to teddy bears due to their soft, cuddly nature.
Originating from the same lineage as Ragdolls, they share a similar temperament, making them beloved for their relaxed and sociable demeanor, capturing the hearts of those they meet.
Turkish Angora
Turkish Angoras, with their long, silky coats and striking eyes, are a vision of grace and beauty. Known for their intelligent and playful nature, they are a delightful presence in any household.
Their stunning appearance and lively personality make them targets for theft. Turkish Angoras are often seen as elegant and refined, captivating those around them.
These cats have a rich history, believed to have originated in the mountains of Turkey, adding a touch of exotic allure to their already enchanting presence.
Exotic Shorthair
The Exotic Shorthair, known for its plush coat and teddy bear-like appearance, captures many hearts. With its round face and gentle expression, this breed is a living embodiment of cuddliness. People often compare them to the Persian, but with a low-maintenance, short coat.
Their laid-back nature makes them perfect for families or individuals seeking a calm companion. These cats love lounging and can adapt well to indoor living, making them prime targets for theft.
Did you know? The Exotic Shorthair was developed by crossing Persians with American Shorthairs, resulting in their unique look and charm.